When One Spouse Wants to Keep the House: Understanding the Buyout Process During Divorce
Recommended procedures for purchasing your spouse’s interest in the marital home while protecting both parties’ financial interests.
By Chris Carter Kent, Associate Broker, Compass
Real Estate Special Commissioner | Divorce Real Estate Specialist (REDS-AZ)
When a couple divorces, one of the most significant financial decisions involves what happens to the marital home. While selling the property and dividing the proceeds may seem like the simplest solution, sometimes one spouse wants to keep the house. Perhaps they want to maintain stability for their children, remain in a home they love, or believe keeping the property makes better financial sense than selling it.
Whatever the reason, buying out a spouse’s interest in the marital home is not always as simple as refinancing the mortgage and removing someone’s name from the deed. Having served as a Real Estate Special Commissioner in court-involved real estate transactions for over a decade, I’ve seen how disagreements over property values, equity, reimbursements, and financing can complicate what initially appears to be a straightforward transaction. Based on that experience, I’ve developed recommended procedures to help divorcing couples navigate the buyout process more efficiently, fairly, and transparently.
First, Understand What a Buyout Really Means
When one spouse wants to keep the marital home, they generally must compensate the other spouse for their share of the equity. For example, suppose the home has a fair market value of $800,000, with an outstanding mortgage of $400,000. This leaves $400,000 in gross equity. Assuming a 50/50 division, each spouse would have a $200,000 share, before accounting for any additional expenses or adjustments.
However, divorce settlements are rarely this simple. There may be reimbursements for mortgage payments, property taxes, repairs, attorney fees, equalization payments, or other financial obligations established in the parties’ agreements, Decree of Dissolution, or Court orders. These amounts can significantly affect what each spouse ultimately receives.
Step 1: Notify Everyone of Your Intent to Purchase
If you want to keep the house, the first step is to communicate your intentions in writing. Notify your spouse, the attorneys, and the Realtor or Real Estate Special Commissioner, if one has been appointed. Your notification should clearly state that you wish to purchase your spouse’s interest in the property. This establishes a documented starting point and allows everyone to understand your intentions before additional expenses or marketing efforts occur. Keep in mind that simply expressing your desire to keep the home does not automatically stop a court-ordered sale. The existing Court orders and applicable deadlines still control.
Step 2: Determine the Fair Market Value
One of the most common disagreements involves the home’s value. The spouse keeping the home may believe it is worth less, while the spouse receiving the buyout may believe it is worth more. Neither party should be expected to accept a value simply because the other spouse proposes it.
I recommend supporting the proposed value with reliable market evidence, such as a professional appraisal completed within the previous 90 days, a Comparative Market Analysis (CMA), a Broker Price Opinion (BPO), recent comparable sales, or written offers from third-party buyers. A genuine third-party offer can be particularly valuable because it provides evidence of what an actual buyer is willing to pay for the property. However, an offer price is not necessarily the final sales price, and financing, contingencies, property condition, and other terms must also be considered. All written third-party offers must be shared with both parties.
Step 3: Submit a Written Buyout Proposal
A buyout proposal should be more than a verbal agreement or an email stating how much one spouse is willing to pay. I recommend preparing a written proposal that includes the proposed property value, the amount to be paid to the other spouse, and an explanation of how that amount was calculated.
The proposal should also address outstanding mortgages, liens, reimbursements, credits, debits, equalization payments, applicable commissions and fees, and any other financial obligations established by the Court. Additionally, it should include a proposed closing date, supporting valuation documents, and evidence that the purchasing spouse has the financial ability to complete the transaction. Both parties and the Special Commissioner should receive the same documentation at the same time. This transparency helps prevent misunderstandings and allows everyone to review the same information.
Step 4: Demonstrate That You Can Afford the Buyout
Wanting to keep the house and being financially qualified to keep it are two different things. Before a buyout can move forward, the purchasing spouse should demonstrate that they have sufficient funds or financing to complete the transaction. This may involve refinancing the existing mortgage, obtaining a new loan, or using available cash. I recommend providing a lender’s prequalification letter, preliminary loan approval, or proof of sufficient funds with the initial proposal.
The lender should also understand that this is a divorce-related, potentially court-ordered transaction and may involve specific escrow instructions, settlement calculations, and title requirements. An important consideration is that removing a spouse from the deed does not necessarily remove that spouse from the mortgage obligation. The parties should confirm with their lender and title company how the existing mortgage will be satisfied, refinanced, or otherwise addressed.
The purchasing spouse must disclose to the new lender and the title company that the property is subject to a divorce-related buyout and that the other spouse has an ownership and financial interest in the transaction. The spouse who is not keeping the home must be included in communications regarding the transfer of title, escrow timelines, closing deadlines, and settlement statements, and must receive the documents and information necessary to review the buyout and their proceeds. A private lender may have confidentiality restrictions concerning the purchasing spouse’s new loan, but those restrictions should not be used to withhold essential transaction information from the other spouse. The existing mortgage lender must also obtain any authorizations required from the parties before discussing or processing matters involving their loan. Both spouses must be given the opportunity to provide necessary authorizations and participate in the title and escrow process.
Step 5: Give the Other Spouse an Opportunity to Review
Once the written proposal and supporting documents have been provided, the other spouse should have a reasonable opportunity to review the information. My recommended procedure allows five business days for an initial written response, unless the parties agree otherwise or the Court establishes a different deadline.
The receiving spouse may accept the proposal or reject it with an explanation. Reasonable concerns might include an unsupported property valuation, missing reimbursements, mathematical errors, insufficient financing, or incomplete documentation. The goal is not to prevent either spouse from disagreeing, but rather to identify the specific issues so they can be evaluated and, hopefully, resolved.
Step 6: What Happens If You Cannot Agree?
Disagreements do not necessarily mean the buyout must fail. Sometimes the parties simply need additional market information, corrected financial calculations, or clarification of the Court’s orders. When serving as a Real Estate Special Commissioner, I may assist by reviewing the proposed valuation, requesting supporting documentation, facilitating communication, and recommending possible solutions.
However, a Special Commissioner is a neutral real estate professional, not an attorney or judge. If the parties cannot reach an agreement, and the Order for Appointment provides the necessary authority, the Special Commissioner may submit the proposal and supporting documentation to the Court for review. The Court can then determine whether to approve, reject, or modify the proposed transaction. The purpose is to provide a path toward resolution rather than allowing disagreements to indefinitely delay the sale or transfer of the property.
Step 7: Open Escrow and Complete the Buyout
Once the parties agree, or the Court approves the buyout, the transaction can proceed through escrow. The title company will need clear instructions regarding the transfer of ownership, payment of mortgages and liens, and distribution of any funds owed between the spouses. The settlement statement should reflect all applicable credits, debits, reimbursements, commissions, fees, and other adjustments. The title company must provide both parties with the applicable escrow timeline, closing deadlines, and settlement statements, and keep both parties informed of material changes.
This is particularly important when the divorce decree includes financial obligations that must be paid from the property’s equity. The parties, their attorneys, the Special Commissioner, and the title company must coordinate to ensure the transaction is completed in accordance with the Court’s orders. A properly documented closing helps protect both spouses and reduces the likelihood of additional disputes after ownership transfers.
Step 8: What If the Purchasing Spouse Cannot Close?
Unfortunately, not every proposed buyout is completed. Financing may be denied, the purchasing spouse may be unable to provide the required funds, or other issues may prevent closing. For this reason, I recommend establishing a specific closing deadline and a clear understanding of what happens if the transaction does not close.
Depending on the Court’s orders, the Special Commissioner may proceed with marketing and selling the home to a third-party buyer or request additional instructions from the Court. A buyout should not become an open-ended process that prevents the other spouse from receiving their share of the equity.
What About the Realtor’s or Special Commissioner’s Compensation?
This is another issue that should be addressed before the buyout is finalized. When a Real Estate Special Commissioner has been appointed to oversee the sale of a property, the Court’s Order for Appointment provides for compensation when the property is sold, refinanced, transferred, or withdrawn from sale following an agreement between the parties. The amount and circumstances of payment depend on the status of the property listing. The party purchasing the home is obligated to pay the Special Commissioner’s fees unless the parties have an additional agreement providing otherwise, subject to the applicable Court orders. The parties should review the compensation provisions when calculating the proposed buyout and anticipated closing expenses.
Why I Recommend a Structured Buyout Procedure
In my experience, many disputes arise not because the parties necessarily disagree about everything, but because there is no clear process for moving forward. One spouse believes the house is worth one amount, while the other believes it is worth something different. Someone questions the mortgage balance, while someone else believes they are entitled to additional reimbursements. Without documentation, deadlines, and a method for resolving disagreements, the process can become unnecessarily expensive and emotionally exhausting.
My recommended procedures are designed to establish transparency, create accountability, and provide a path toward resolution. Both parties must receive the same financial information and supporting documentation. Written proposals, reasonable deadlines, and evidence of financing help keep the process moving. When the parties cannot agree, the issues can be clearly identified and, when appropriate, presented to the Court.
These procedures are recommendations based on my experience handling complex, court-involved real estate transactions. They do not replace the parties’ agreements, Decree of Dissolution, Order for Appointment, or subsequent Court orders. Each party should consult their own attorney regarding their legal rights and obligations.
Final Thoughts: Keeping the House Should Be a Financial Decision, Not Just an Emotional One
I understand why someone may want to keep the marital home. A house represents more than its market value. It may hold years of memories, provide stability for children, or represent an important part of someone’s financial future. But keeping the home must also make financial sense. Before committing to a buyout, consider not only whether you can qualify for the financing, but whether you can comfortably afford the mortgage, property taxes, insurance, maintenance, and future repairs on your own.
And if you are the spouse receiving the buyout, you deserve a transparent process that provides a reasonable valuation, proper accounting of the equity, and a timely closing. A successful buyout should allow both parties to move forward with confidence that the transaction was handled fairly, professionally, and in accordance with their agreements and Court orders.
Chris Carter Kent is an Associate Broker with Compass, a Divorce Real Estate Specialist (REDS-AZ), and an experienced Court-Appointed Real Estate Special Commissioner. With more than a decade of experience handling complex real estate transactions involving legal, financial, and emotional challenges, she helps divorcing couples navigate the sale or transfer of real property with an emphasis on neutrality, transparency, and effective communication.
This article is provided for educational purposes and does not constitute legal, tax, or financial advice.